Snape showed him that memory to let Harry know he was the one who put the sword in the lake and led Harry to it. Like would the sword have done nothing if Snape has just stabbed it into a tree? But not this one. Fashioned from pure silver, it is inset with rubies, the stone that represents Gryffindor in the hour-glasses that count the house points at Hogwarts. It's possible it would just be a regular sword in their hands, or that it would return to its resting place at Hogwarts. A/N We know the story of Arthur and how he pulled the sword out of the stone, but another version of the story is when the Lady of the Lake handed the sword over to Merlin (or Arthur, depending on which legend). ... Basically this, snape put the sword there, even in splitting the film in two they missed (or changed) quite a few things. I don't think it would've been very hard to keep tabs on them somehow. "You could put the sword in there for Harry Potter to find!" The other scene with Snape's patronus, where Harry is in the woods, happened after Dumbledore died. He was tracking Harry/Hermione by the portrait in her bag. The house colors represent the elements. ... Deathly Hallows that the Sword of Gryffindor is supposed to be in Bellatrix Lestrange's vault, placed there by Severus Snape. 7 days ago. I get that he didn’t want to just walk up to him and reveal himself, but surely there was a slightly less complicated way? You have to display Gryffindor values and be in need of the sword to be allowed to use it for as long as your need exists. Snape put the sword in the pool because he couldn't let Harry see him, because Harry still thought he was on the bad side. After reading the book, it's clear that in the office, he only was showing his Patronus to make a point that it was a doe, like Lily's, and he later casts the Patronus to take Harry to the pond (I don't want to give much else away since you haven't read that yet), Oh, that makes so much sense! Press J to jump to the feed. Though they’ve said in the films the sword finds its way to those who need it most/in their time … If Snape just left the sword lying around for Harry to pick up, it’s magic either wouldn’t have worked or it would have returned to it’s place in Hogwarts (it’s unclear on the specifics here). As Ron and Hermione emerged, spluttering and gasping, from the depths of the lake, the dragon flew on, its wings beating hard, and landed at last on a distant bank. How would Snape even know Harry would be there? Then there is the whole not wanting to be seen by Harry or Ron. Harry Potter's Patronus is a stag. Snape casts the Patronus in Dumbledore's office to show him that he still cares for Lily. If Snape sent the patronus while Dumbledore was still alive why did it get to the lake so much later? It's clear that Snape is a powerful wizard but wouldn't have a lot of the experience that most other headmasters did. He hadn't even noticed that the elf had walked away, though Severus realized that he should have from the dead silence. We use a [Watsonian point of view](http://fanlore.org/wiki/Watsonian_vs._Doylist), versus Doylist.  The other scene with Snape's patronus, where Harry is in the woods, happened after Dumbledore died. Again, he was only put in the position to protect the children from the Death Eaters. It's the reason why Rowling decided to have Snape put the sword in the lake in the forest for Harry to find in the original story. If Snape sent the patronus while Dumbledore was still alive why did it get to the lake so much later? Snape has to make sure Harry was able to get the sword without directly communicating with him in any way (because of the mind connection to LV) and had to establish some sort of bravery test. And after Ron showed up again to save Harry at the frozen lake, he mentions having seen a hint of movement between a pair of trees in the distance -- it's implied Snape was there the whole time, to put the sword in the lake and control the Patronus that led Harry to it. He needed to be a double agent in Voldemort's ranks in order to be able to help Harry & Co on their quest, such as when he sent his doe Patronus to the lake where he hid the sword of Godric Gryffindor. Harry and Hermione travel back in time to when they were standing on the other side of the lake. Snape was not present in the showdown at the Ministry of Magic at the end of book 5, so he may not know that Harry has already cast an Unforgivable Curse. Like the others have mentioned, it needs an act of bravery to work in some fashion. Plus, Snape … As for the lake, all Snape had to do was melt a small bit of the ice, suspend the sword in the water, and freeze the ice back over with his wand. He is the one who journeys to the Forest of Dean and leaves the sword in the lake. This Patronus is in the form of a stag. While this isn't wrong, its not really on-topic for the post. Godric Gryffindor's name is engraved just beneath the hilt.The sword was made to Godric Gryffindor's specifi… Hence Past-Harry sees a stag on other side of the lake. I thought that as well when I saw the movie, I kept thinking "how on earth did the Patronus get there and why did it take so long??" Future-Harry sees that Dementors are sucking the souls of Harry and Sirius and casts the Patronus. Thank you for clearing that up :). Snape didn't place the sword into the vault himself; he handed the (fake) sword to Bellatrix (presumably, or to her husband, or to her brother-in-law, it makes no difference), and they went to Gringotts and ordered it to be put in their vault — which was personally done by Griphook, in the one single time he went to the Lestrange's vault. Unknown to Bellatrix, that sword was only a replica. … This one actually has more complicated magic involving the person wishing to obtain it needing to demonstrate Gryffindor values of bravery. But this is the kind of magic that is subtle, and significantly more powerful than anything you can do with a wand. Deluminator (Put-Outer) ... Rowling has confirmed that Gryffindor did not steal the sword from Ragnuk and that this belief is merely part of Griphook's goblin mistrust and prejudice against wizards. Professor Snape learns of Harry and Ron’s whereabouts from asking the portrait of Phineas Nigellus Black. ...find the sword of Godric Gryffindor in some random ass pond? Rowling has confirmed in her webchat that Gryffindor did not steal the sword from Ragnuk and that this belief is merely part of Griphook's goblin mistrust and prejudice against wizards. A lot of the info I've looked up says Snape did send the pond Patronus in Dumbledore's office when he was taking the sword of Gryyfindor, but I can't understand 1) how they would know exactly where harry would be & 2) why he had to sent the patronus in the future? He also has a portrait in the Headmaster's office. Sry for bad english :-), New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the harrypotter community. He then produces his Patronus to lead Harry to the spot. Snape's timely spell-casting prevents Harry from uttering an Unforgivable Curse. There are many interesting connections to be made through … The house colors represent the elements. Do not forget that it must be taken under conditions of need and valor — and he must not know that you give it! Who stole the Gryffindor sword? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the AskScienceFiction community. This is pretty much the definitive answer. He threw it in the lake because it was near where they were camping. Snape put it in the pond. After Dumbledore’s death, Dumbledore’s portrait instructs Professor Snape to put the sword in the lake for Harry and Ron to find. Significantly, Snape protects Harry, in a sense. We're not disagreeing that Snape hates Harry's guts, but this isn't Snape's usual "Grainger answered a question without raising her hand high enough, eleventy-billion points from Griffindor" power trip; there is a bona fide reason in this case. But not too much as to actually hurt them. The sword of Godric is a magical artefact beholden to Hogwarts. Harry Potter's Patronus is a stag. The dragon did not seem to have noticed anything; it was already fifty feet away, swooping low over the lake to scoop up water in its scarred snout. Snape- You are aware that the sword must be taken with bravery? The answer to most questions of this kind are usually just Snape is a huge asshole. As /u/benigndepressedbear mentioned, to properly claim the sword, Harry couldn't just pluck it out of a tree. It's like Ask Science, but for all universes other than our own. It was confirmed that the sword in the lake was, in fact, the real sword of Gryffindor because Ronald Weasley was able to kill the horcrux locket that tried to kill Harry at the lake. Which makes sense if he was trying to conjure it from the Sorting Hat but makes less sense when it is physically in his area. And after Ron showed up again to save Harry at the frozen lake, he mentions having seen a hint of movement between a pair of trees in the distance -- it's implied Snape was there the whole time, to put the sword in the lake and control the Patronus that led Harry to it. When Harry looks in the Pensieve he seems Snape casting a patronus in Dumbledore's office, but the patronus doesn't get to the lake & Harry months until after Dumbledore dies so how is this possible? Future-Harry sees that Dementors are sucking the souls of Harry and Sirius and casts the Patronus. Hermione had taken the portrait of Phineas Black from Grimmald Place and put it in her purse. Who put the sword in the lake? I've seen the movies but haven't read the books 6 & 7 so it might be explained in there somewhere. Hence Past-Harry sees a stag on other side of the lake… He put it at the bottom of a frozen lake and then led him to it with his patronus. ... why'd you have to put the sword in the freaking water. In Harry Potter’s magical world, nothing is as it seems—and that goes for the books themselves. Or did I miss something. There are deep (biblical) reason behind this that I won't spell out here to prevent my AN from becoming longer than this story's chapter.
One Chip Challenge Nz, Silver Sands Chapin Beach, Strangers 2 Soundtrack, How To Remove Wax Buildup From Linoleum, Kramer Striker V, Chao Garden Mobile Game,